Custom Search

Monday, June 10, 2019

Suspected Bot List [2019-06-09]

detection period: 2019-06-09 00:00-23:59 UTC
number of suspected bots' IPs listed here: 724

IP addresses listed here all exhibit strange network behavior. As I could not notify the victims for various reasons (no working abuse contact, mailbox over quota, etc.), I list them here instead. I have to emphasize that those are just *suspected* to be malware-infected computers.

List from fake open relays:

country codeIP addressCountry

List from greylisting:


country codeIP addressCountry

List from SSH probes:

country codeIP addressCountry
ES217.127.237.153Spain
PL109.241.71.16Poland

List from TCP port scans:

country codeIP addressCountry
AO196.29.193.74Angola
AR190.216.64.2Argentina
AR190.216.136.34Argentina
AR190.217.1.75Argentina
AR190.217.7.19Argentina
AR190.217.20.2Argentina
AR190.217.55.162Argentina
AR190.217.71.15Argentina
AR200.0.236.210Argentina
AR200.32.100.222Argentina
AR201.234.224.14Argentina
BB200.50.67.105Barbados
BD45.124.169.59Bangladesh
BD45.124.170.195Bangladesh
BD45.124.170.196Bangladesh
BD103.110.220.82Bangladesh
BE85.28.83.23Belgium
BH84.255.152.10Bahrain
BH88.201.64.185Bahrain
BI154.119.7.3Burundi
BR150.161.8.120Brazil
BW41.223.142.211Botswana
BW129.205.208.20Botswana
BW129.205.208.21Botswana
BW129.205.208.22Botswana
BW129.205.208.23Botswana
BW168.167.85.255Botswana
CA24.80.64.197Canada
CA50.71.97.118Canada
CA70.70.7.9Canada
CA96.48.244.48Canada
CA149.248.81.245Canada
CA174.7.235.9Canada
CD41.190.232.67Democratic Republic Of Congo
CD197.231.252.90Democratic Republic Of Congo
CI105.235.116.254Ivory Coast
CM41.191.101.4Cameroon
CM41.211.116.32Cameroon
CM41.211.122.245Cameroon
CM169.255.7.94Cameroon
CM195.24.198.17Cameroon
CM195.24.207.199Cameroon
CM195.24.207.250Cameroon
CN62.234.8.41China
CN62.234.8.213China
CN62.234.17.111China
CN62.234.72.154China
CN62.234.73.104China
CN62.234.93.251China
CN62.234.103.7China
CN62.234.108.63China
CN62.234.108.245China
CN62.234.119.16China
CN62.234.133.230China
CN62.234.136.217China
CN62.234.153.11China
CN62.234.172.19China
CN62.234.201.168China
CN62.234.206.12China
CN62.234.219.27China
CN94.191.3.81China
CN94.191.8.31China
CN94.191.10.77China
CN94.191.15.73China
CN94.191.20.179China
CN94.191.28.110China
CN94.191.29.221China
CN94.191.31.230China
CN94.191.41.77China
CN94.191.47.85China
CN94.191.68.83China
CN94.191.68.224China
CN94.191.69.141China
CN94.191.79.156China
CN94.191.81.131China
CN94.191.87.180China
CN94.191.87.254China
CN94.191.99.114China
CN94.191.102.171China
CN94.191.103.139China
CN188.131.128.138China
CN188.131.132.70China
CN188.131.134.157China
CN188.131.140.115China
CN188.131.146.22China
CN188.131.153.127China
CN188.131.153.253China
CN188.131.154.248China
CN188.131.171.12China
CN188.131.185.73China
CN188.131.186.207China
CN188.131.194.34China
CN188.131.200.191China
CN188.131.204.154China
CN188.131.215.177China
CN188.131.228.31China
CN188.131.241.152China
CN188.131.244.80China
CN188.131.244.130China
CN188.131.244.197China
CN188.131.246.151China
CN193.112.4.12China
CN193.112.9.213China
CN193.112.12.183China
CN193.112.23.81China
CN193.112.26.73China
CN193.112.28.150China
CN193.112.44.21China
CN193.112.45.93China
CN193.112.46.79China
CN193.112.46.99China
CN193.112.48.179China
CN193.112.49.155China
CN193.112.52.201China
CN193.112.58.212China
CN193.112.66.61China
CN193.112.68.27China
CN193.112.72.126China
CN193.112.72.180China
CN193.112.78.37China
CN193.112.85.80China
CN193.112.86.98China
CN193.112.87.125China
CN193.112.90.146China
CN193.112.94.153China
CN193.112.94.220China
CN193.112.97.157China
CN193.112.107.84China
CN193.112.111.174China
CN193.112.139.161China
CN193.112.160.221China
CN193.112.174.67China
CN193.112.174.110China
CN193.112.191.228China
CN193.112.213.48China
CN193.112.213.148China
CN193.112.219.228China
CN193.112.220.76China
CN193.112.241.141China
CN193.112.251.73China
CN212.64.7.134China
CN212.64.11.188China
CN212.64.23.30China
CN212.64.26.131China
CN212.64.27.235China
CN212.64.28.77China
CN212.64.32.162China
CN212.64.39.109China
CN212.64.44.165China
CN212.64.59.94China
CN212.64.87.81China
CN212.64.91.66China
CN212.64.91.146China
CN212.64.94.179China
CN212.64.98.195China
CN212.64.109.31China
CN212.129.128.249China
CO132.255.22.90Colombia
CO170.254.228.136Colombia
CO181.225.65.243Colombia
CO190.0.243.226Colombia
CO190.107.19.162Colombia
CO190.107.28.147Colombia
CR163.178.106.190Costa Rica
CR186.26.124.170Costa Rica
DE116.203.130.205Germany
DE116.203.188.211Germany
DE153.92.5.4Germany
DE153.92.5.183Germany
DZ193.194.77.194Algeria
DZ193.194.79.158Algeria
DZ193.194.91.133Algeria
DZ197.201.214.94Algeria
EG41.65.64.36Egypt
EG41.65.68.68Egypt
EG41.65.160.78Egypt
EG41.65.218.72Egypt
EG41.65.226.142Egypt
EG41.65.231.2Egypt
EG41.130.166.0Egypt
EG41.196.0.189Egypt
EG45.240.75.230Egypt
EG82.129.186.65Egypt
EG102.184.187.32Egypt
EG196.156.64.150Egypt
EG196.204.141.66Egypt
EG196.216.206.2Egypt
EG196.221.86.0Egypt
EG196.221.147.17Egypt
EG196.221.166.15Egypt
EG197.135.6.41Egypt
EG217.139.15.114Egypt
ES2.136.114.40Spain
ES2.139.193.157Spain
ES2.139.199.51Spain
ES2.139.209.78Spain
ES79.147.252.154Spain
ES79.150.176.157Spain
ES79.151.243.208Spain
ES79.153.114.70Spain
ES79.154.126.225Spain
ES79.155.195.63Spain
ES79.157.240.57Spain
ES79.159.192.217Spain
ES80.24.191.81Spain
ES80.25.83.188Spain
ES80.25.123.28Spain
ES80.28.234.134Spain
ES80.32.104.188Spain
ES80.37.231.233Spain
ES81.32.74.57Spain
ES81.32.137.44Spain
ES81.32.226.243Spain
ES81.35.254.30Spain
ES81.36.238.177Spain
ES81.37.72.102Spain
ES81.45.27.132Spain
ES81.47.128.178Spain
ES83.43.60.26Spain
ES83.48.29.116Spain
ES83.48.89.147Spain
ES83.50.174.75Spain
ES83.55.220.88Spain
ES83.56.32.9Spain
ES88.7.224.57Spain
ES88.12.11.108Spain
ES88.12.27.44Spain
ES88.26.236.2Spain
ES88.28.204.229Spain
ES88.28.211.226Spain
ES95.123.135.123Spain
ES150.214.150.144Spain
ES176.84.51.123Spain
ES176.84.112.183Spain
ES212.170.153.76Spain
ES213.96.132.215Spain
ES213.97.245.39Spain
ES213.98.14.184Spain
ES217.124.185.164Spain
ES217.125.110.139Spain
ET196.189.88.50Ethiopia
ET196.189.88.170Ethiopia
ET197.156.69.60Ethiopia
ET197.156.72.154Ethiopia
ET197.156.104.113Ethiopia
FR5.49.163.128France
FR51.81.7.54France
FR62.34.210.232France
FR80.215.234.136France
FR89.80.122.200France
FR89.88.79.210France
FR89.90.209.252France
FR176.159.208.68France
FR176.175.111.67France
FR176.184.166.218France
GA41.78.243.213Gabon
GA41.159.18.20Gabon
GA41.159.138.156Gabon
GB27.110.4.30United Kingdom
GH41.66.206.146Ghana
GH41.189.187.235Ghana
GH41.191.244.2Ghana
GH129.122.16.156Ghana
GH196.29.228.113Ghana
GH196.43.196.108Ghana
GH197.251.253.141Ghana
GN41.191.222.148Guinea
GN102.176.160.29Guinea
HK103.224.250.136Hong Kong
ID103.42.252.130Indonesia
ID103.52.16.35Indonesia
ID103.57.195.27Indonesia
ID103.57.195.201Indonesia
ID103.104.12.115Indonesia
ID103.108.158.131Indonesia
ID103.111.81.142Indonesia
ID103.111.83.222Indonesia
ID103.124.90.149Indonesia
ID103.253.107.246Indonesia
ID119.252.171.186Indonesia
ID182.16.245.54Indonesia
ID202.162.208.202Indonesia
ID220.247.175.58Indonesia
IN42.108.241.242India
IN43.242.215.70India
IN45.124.145.150India
IN45.124.146.3India
IN45.124.146.181India
IN45.124.147.26India
IN103.22.173.226India
IN103.38.14.33India
IN103.38.36.29India
IN103.248.83.76India
IN103.248.83.78India
IN103.249.76.231India
IN113.21.64.129India
IN118.185.32.18India
IN118.185.186.194India
IN119.235.48.204India
IN119.235.48.244India
IR103.231.136.180Iran
IT82.85.143.181Italy
IT84.221.181.24Italy
IT94.36.15.91Italy
IT217.133.58.148Italy
IT217.133.99.111Italy
JP61.120.152.11Japan
JP133.130.88.87Japan
JP133.130.103.206Japan
JP133.130.117.173Japan
JP133.130.119.178Japan
JP133.175.89.149Japan
JP153.135.78.62Japan
JP153.149.156.35Japan
JP153.166.254.29Japan
JP153.195.119.158Japan
JP153.254.113.26Japan
JP202.247.60.253Japan
JP210.129.184.15Japan
JP210.136.250.54Japan
JP210.157.255.252Japan
JP210.196.153.9Japan
JP210.227.113.18Japan
JP218.219.246.124Japan
JP219.105.33.26Japan
JP219.109.200.107Japan
JP220.98.13.36Japan
KE41.89.33.4Kenya
KE41.90.118.138Kenya
KE41.204.191.53Kenya
KE41.206.33.158Kenya
KE41.206.60.6Kenya
KE41.215.33.186Kenya
KE41.215.142.32Kenya
KE41.223.58.67Kenya
KE62.12.115.116Kenya
KE62.24.102.106Kenya
KE169.255.10.162Kenya
KE197.232.16.104Kenya
KE197.232.47.210Kenya
KE197.232.52.61Kenya
KE197.232.53.182Kenya
KE197.232.242.120Kenya
KE197.248.16.118Kenya
KE197.248.141.10Kenya
KE197.248.161.130Kenya
KE212.22.188.190Kenya
KR203.234.211.246South Korea
KR203.235.116.121South Korea
KR203.245.41.187South Korea
KR203.245.41.236South Korea
KR210.90.69.101South Korea
KR211.116.226.92South Korea
KR211.185.154.3South Korea
KR219.240.111.44South Korea
KW168.187.15.227Kuwait
KW168.187.61.244Kuwait
KW168.187.142.30Kuwait
KW168.187.143.184Kuwait
KW168.187.153.237Kuwait
KW168.187.190.82Kuwait
KW168.187.250.156Kuwait
KZ85.159.27.40Kazakhstan
LB185.82.98.46Lebanon
LB185.82.98.219Lebanon
LK112.134.152.19Sri Lanka
LK112.134.195.12Sri Lanka
LK124.43.16.104Sri Lanka
LK124.43.17.69Sri Lanka
LK203.115.14.115Sri Lanka
LS154.66.110.240Lesotho
LY41.208.68.31Libya
LY165.16.67.130Libya
MA41.137.137.92Morocco
MA41.141.250.244Morocco
MA81.192.159.130Morocco
MA81.192.169.192Morocco
MA154.148.235.210Morocco
MA194.204.214.167Morocco
MA196.73.60.117Morocco
MA196.79.9.189Morocco
MA196.87.143.187Morocco
MA196.200.181.5Morocco
MA197.128.197.133Morocco
MA197.247.8.58Morocco
MA197.247.57.133Morocco
MG41.188.51.199Madagascar
ML154.118.141.90Mali
MU41.60.239.133Mauritius
MU41.72.219.102Mauritius
MU41.77.145.34Mauritius
MU41.77.146.98Mauritius
MU105.27.143.190Mauritius
MU154.120.242.70Mauritius
MU196.27.127.61Mauritius
MU197.211.225.66Mauritius
MU197.211.229.56Mauritius
MU197.224.142.63Mauritius
MU197.226.19.250Mauritius
MW41.75.123.8Malawi
MW41.75.123.19Malawi
MW154.66.122.90Malawi
MX148.235.57.183Mexico
MX148.235.57.184Mexico
MX168.255.251.126Mexico
MX187.131.80.43Mexico
MX187.131.133.7Mexico
MX187.135.36.76Mexico
MX187.135.190.200Mexico
MX187.135.213.233Mexico
MX187.136.221.115Mexico
MX187.141.176.34Mexico
MX187.148.33.145Mexico
MX187.154.159.55Mexico
MX187.154.223.220Mexico
MX187.157.144.196Mexico
MX187.157.167.34Mexico
MX187.174.159.82Mexico
MX187.200.119.209Mexico
MX187.200.146.8Mexico
MX187.210.126.57Mexico
MX187.214.72.53Mexico
MX187.216.125.212Mexico
MX187.216.127.147Mexico
MX187.217.124.179Mexico
MX187.217.199.20Mexico
MX187.217.205.50Mexico
MX187.217.207.27Mexico
MX187.218.51.148Mexico
MX187.222.79.57Mexico
MX187.228.158.199Mexico
MX187.235.187.20Mexico
MX187.237.123.210Mexico
MX187.237.251.119Mexico
MX189.129.148.104Mexico
MX189.130.242.68Mexico
MX189.134.122.47Mexico
MX189.139.128.57Mexico
MX189.146.242.84Mexico
MX189.149.129.161Mexico
MX189.149.171.127Mexico
MX189.152.210.73Mexico
MX189.154.23.243Mexico
MX189.155.129.221Mexico
MX189.156.202.124Mexico
MX189.161.15.92Mexico
MX189.161.120.31Mexico
MX189.163.155.180Mexico
MX189.165.105.240Mexico
MX189.175.129.16Mexico
MX189.225.32.155Mexico
MX189.229.5.149Mexico
MX189.230.82.168Mexico
MX189.238.28.35Mexico
MX189.240.6.157Mexico
MX189.240.27.194Mexico
MX189.244.242.129Mexico
MX189.248.140.152Mexico
MX189.252.17.215Mexico
MX189.252.95.125Mexico
MX189.253.81.39Mexico
MX189.254.33.157Mexico
MX189.254.94.227Mexico
MX201.111.125.4Mexico
MX201.114.254.14Mexico
MX201.116.12.217Mexico
MX201.123.116.8Mexico
MX201.137.252.250Mexico
MX201.144.84.93Mexico
MX201.144.119.52Mexico
MX201.145.162.167Mexico
MZ41.76.149.212Mozambique
MZ41.77.129.202Mozambique
MZ41.220.205.75Mozambique
MZ165.90.69.210Mozambique
MZ196.3.99.146Mozambique
MZ197.235.10.121Mozambique
MZ197.249.5.15Mozambique
NA41.182.110.207Namibia
NA196.216.56.138Namibia
NG41.67.143.54Nigeria
NG41.73.158.66Nigeria
NG41.73.234.195Nigeria
NG41.75.82.138Nigeria
NG41.75.93.186Nigeria
NG41.76.81.89Nigeria
NG41.79.64.75Nigeria
NG41.87.72.102Nigeria
NG41.87.72.124Nigeria
NG41.206.5.190Nigeria
NG41.216.174.202Nigeria
NG41.221.168.167Nigeria
NG41.221.168.168Nigeria
NG81.26.64.34Nigeria
NG105.112.10.10Nigeria
NG105.112.33.64Nigeria
NG105.235.201.251Nigeria
NG154.113.0.202Nigeria
NG154.118.52.188Nigeria
NG196.11.231.220Nigeria
NG197.211.35.163Nigeria
NG197.234.39.158Nigeria
NG197.253.23.121Nigeria
NG212.100.68.101Nigeria
NL31.207.47.71Netherlands
NL185.244.25.107Netherlands
NL185.244.25.112Netherlands
NL185.244.25.121Netherlands
NL185.244.25.128Netherlands
NL185.244.25.129Netherlands
NL185.244.25.130Netherlands
NL185.244.25.131Netherlands
NL185.244.25.136Netherlands
NL185.244.25.139Netherlands
NL185.244.25.141Netherlands
NL185.244.25.142Netherlands
NL185.244.25.143Netherlands
NL185.244.25.144Netherlands
NL185.244.25.149Netherlands
NL185.244.25.150Netherlands
NL185.244.25.151Netherlands
NL185.244.25.152Netherlands
NL185.244.25.153Netherlands
NL185.244.25.158Netherlands
NL185.244.25.212Netherlands
NZ122.58.13.28New Zealand
NZ122.59.44.246New Zealand
NZ210.54.33.73New Zealand
NZ219.88.235.122New Zealand
PE161.132.194.172Peru
PK39.35.247.150Pakistan
PK39.45.21.20Pakistan
PK39.46.42.207Pakistan
PK39.61.53.93Pakistan
PK103.213.115.249Pakistan
PK115.186.156.164Pakistan
PK115.186.175.106Pakistan
PK119.159.229.247Pakistan
PK124.29.205.2Pakistan
PK124.29.244.50Pakistan
PK124.109.32.106Pakistan
PK137.59.226.9Pakistan
PK137.59.226.98Pakistan
PK175.107.196.29Pakistan
PK175.107.196.235Pakistan
PK182.176.87.211Pakistan
PK182.176.170.166Pakistan
PK182.180.119.150Pakistan
PK182.180.163.223Pakistan
PK182.184.44.6Pakistan
PK182.184.64.170Pakistan
PK182.191.113.10Pakistan
PK202.163.126.134Pakistan
PK203.99.57.114Pakistan
PK203.99.57.115Pakistan
PK203.99.62.158Pakistan
PK203.101.174.2Pakistan
PL91.90.188.100Poland
PL93.105.58.83Poland
RU46.161.27.17Russian Federation
RU46.161.27.51Russian Federation
RU176.32.129.181Russian Federation
SA82.118.164.21Saudi Arabia
SA82.118.170.151Saudi Arabia
SD41.67.39.6Sudan
SD41.67.59.14Sudan
SD196.223.156.1Sudan
SD197.251.12.5Sudan
SD197.254.193.222Sudan
SL196.216.220.204Sierra Leone
SN41.82.213.66Senegal
SN41.82.254.90Senegal
SN41.214.20.60Senegal
SN196.1.99.12Senegal
SO41.79.198.34Somalia
SO41.79.199.37Somalia
SO197.231.202.128Somalia
TG160.242.192.104Togo
TN41.224.59.78Tunisia
TN41.226.12.231Tunisia
TN41.227.31.122Tunisia
TN41.228.12.149Tunisia
TN41.228.163.221Tunisia
TN102.156.49.49Tunisia
TN160.157.109.237Tunisia
TN165.50.244.203Tunisia
TN196.179.231.103Tunisia
TN196.203.31.154Tunisia
TN197.2.227.3Tunisia
TN197.31.113.105Tunisia
TW203.66.168.81Taiwan
TW210.59.145.167Taiwan
TW210.61.148.57Taiwan
TW210.240.163.80Taiwan
TW210.242.144.34Taiwan
TW211.20.151.172Taiwan
TW211.21.137.199Taiwan
TW211.21.154.4Taiwan
TW211.22.154.8Taiwan
TW211.22.154.225Taiwan
TW211.22.167.12Taiwan
TW211.75.19.61Taiwan
TW211.75.76.138Taiwan
TW211.75.191.32Taiwan
TW211.75.193.168Taiwan
TW211.75.194.80Taiwan
TW218.164.62.207Taiwan
TW218.164.108.202Taiwan
TW218.166.27.124Taiwan
TW218.166.62.28Taiwan
TW218.166.117.240Taiwan
TW218.166.244.37Taiwan
TW218.173.34.95Taiwan
TW218.173.129.135Taiwan
TW218.173.135.178Taiwan
TW218.173.147.227Taiwan
TW218.173.153.173Taiwan
TZ41.59.25.2Tanzania
TZ41.59.57.152Tanzania
TZ41.59.87.90Tanzania
TZ41.59.192.43Tanzania
TZ41.74.112.12Tanzania
TZ41.75.211.202Tanzania
TZ197.250.10.76Tanzania
UA89.185.1.175Ukraine
UA89.185.8.121Ukraine
UG41.138.208.141Uganda
UG41.202.238.22Uganda
UG41.210.128.37Uganda
UG41.221.91.210Uganda
UG129.205.15.174Uganda
UG137.63.184.100Uganda
UG137.63.199.2Uganda
UG154.66.219.20Uganda
UG154.72.194.1Uganda
UG154.72.199.38Uganda
UG196.0.113.90Uganda
UG196.0.117.14Uganda
UG196.43.152.254Uganda
UG196.43.178.1Uganda
UG212.88.123.198Uganda
US18.93.6.92United States
US209.217.192.148United States
VE150.188.8.208Venezuela
ZA41.76.209.14South Africa
ZA41.78.201.48South Africa
ZA41.79.82.46South Africa
ZA41.138.93.243South Africa
ZA41.160.233.156South Africa
ZA41.161.15.165South Africa
ZA41.164.76.22South Africa
ZA41.164.78.60South Africa
ZA41.164.195.204South Africa
ZA41.169.18.58South Africa
ZA41.169.70.219South Africa
ZA41.169.122.11South Africa
ZA41.180.68.214South Africa
ZA41.198.59.42South Africa
ZA41.216.186.87South Africa
ZA41.222.136.3South Africa
ZA45.220.30.99South Africa
ZA102.129.58.22South Africa
ZA102.132.250.5South Africa
ZA102.165.50.10South Africa
ZA105.208.58.217South Africa
ZA105.208.59.31South Africa
ZA105.212.100.71South Africa
ZA105.216.7.248South Africa
ZA105.233.35.69South Africa
ZA105.247.157.59South Africa
ZA105.247.158.94South Africa
ZA105.247.179.162South Africa
ZA105.247.244.235South Africa
ZA129.205.135.171South Africa
ZA129.205.138.174South Africa
ZA154.0.170.9South Africa
ZA154.65.53.174South Africa
ZA154.66.113.78South Africa
ZA154.70.131.104South Africa
ZA154.70.249.92South Africa
ZA154.73.137.189South Africa
ZA154.117.159.218South Africa
ZA154.117.169.66South Africa
ZA154.119.224.133South Africa
ZA156.38.136.202South Africa
ZA156.155.9.141South Africa
ZA156.155.9.159South Africa
ZA160.20.252.15South Africa
ZA160.119.253.57South Africa
ZA168.128.86.35South Africa
ZA169.0.161.246South Africa
ZA169.1.16.214South Africa
ZA169.1.92.132South Africa
ZA169.255.63.162South Africa
ZA169.255.196.156South Africa
ZA196.35.41.86South Africa
ZA196.36.153.172South Africa
ZA196.38.84.246South Africa
ZA196.41.126.22South Africa
ZA196.41.127.181South Africa
ZA196.47.67.180South Africa
ZA196.52.43.118South Africa
ZA196.61.225.214South Africa
ZA196.210.49.111South Africa
ZA196.212.101.42South Africa
ZA196.250.32.37South Africa
ZA196.251.8.40South Africa
ZA197.96.44.122South Africa
ZA197.96.136.91South Africa
ZA197.97.230.93South Africa
ZA197.98.121.130South Africa
ZA197.242.155.108South Africa
ZA213.150.207.5South Africa
ZA213.150.207.97South Africa
ZA216.236.177.108South Africa
ZM41.72.105.171Zambia
ZM155.0.56.9Zambia
ZW41.85.201.83Zimbabwe
ZW41.221.146.138Zimbabwe
ZW196.29.32.249Zimbabwe
ZW196.29.33.118Zimbabwe
ZW197.221.249.12Zimbabwe

No comments:

Post a Comment